Screening calls for receptionist: Expert tips + tools

You can’t afford to treat every call the same. Some bring in new customers, others waste time, and a few can even derail your day. Screening calls for receptionists helps you separate the important from the irrelevant. So you keep your focus where it matters.

Whether you’re a receptionist managing calls or a business owner, this guide breaks down how to screen calls well and what tools can make it easier.

What is call screening? 

Call screening is the process of reviewing incoming phone calls to decide how you’ll answer them. This could be chatting with the caller, taking a message, or redirecting them with a warm transfer.

The goal is to make sure every call gets the right attention from the right person at the right time. Screening calls also protects you from interruptions. For example, spam calls or people accidentally calling the wrong number.

Here’s what you need to determine while screening calls:

• Who is the caller?
• What company/organization are they from?
• What is the purpose of their call?
• Is this a legitimate business inquiry or an unwanted sales pitch/robocall?
• How urgent is their request?
• Who is the best person to handle this type of call, and are they available?

But is screening calls rude? No, quite the opposite. Call screening improves the caller experience by getting them to where they need to go more quickly. It also lets you personalize interactions more. Call filtering won’t make you lose customers. Instead, it’ll show them you care about delivering professional customer service.

💡Tip: You may have heard call screening referred to as call handling. But these aren’t the same. Call handling is your general approach to managing incoming calls. It’s a broader approach that also covers what happens after you’ve screened a call.

What’s the purpose of screening phone calls? 

Here’s why every growing business needs a call screening process:

• Improve time management: Call screening helps your team focus on important tasks without constant unnecessary disruptions.  
• Improve customer service: By routing calls to the right person immediately, your customers can get help faster. They also don’t get bounced around between departments. 
• Prioritize which missed calls to answer first: Not every caller needs a lightning-fast response. Screening can help you identify emergencies and prioritize callers who need immediate attention.
• Screen out spam calls, robocallers, and telemarketers: Stop wasting time on callers who won’t actually become customers.
• Address call volume as you grow: With effective screening, your team won’t spend extra time on spam and misdirected calls. So you can handle more calls with fewer staff.
• Handle calls while out of the office: Some call screening tools come with after-hours call management features. These let you set up workflows for off-hours so customers still get help while you’re out.

How does the screening process work? 

For receptionists who handle screening manually, the process requires:

1. Call detection and interception. When a call comes in, it’s first captured by your screening system. That could be a human receptionist, an answering service, or an AI receptionist like Sona.
2. Caller identification and initial assessment. The screener gathers basic information‌ about ‌who’s calling, the company they’re from, and what the call’s about. This involves asking questions like “May I ask what this is concerning?” Or “Will the person you’re trying to reach know what this is about?”
3. Call evaluation and decision-making. The screener decides whether it’s a priority call, a routine inquiry, a sales call, or an emergency based on the information gathered. This could be real-time details from the caller or stored details in your CRM.
4. Call routing or response. Your screener directs the caller to where they need to go. If the person they need is unavailable, they could leave a voicemail or schedule a callback. 
5. Documentation and after-call work. Finally, the screener logs important details like caller information, call purpose, and outcome. This is also the time to assign follow-up actions.

Business phone systems like Quo, formerly OpenPhone, automate much of this process with features like business hours, call routing, and IVR menus.

Step	Process	Example
Call detection and interception	A human or software system takes the incoming call.	The phone rings at 2 p.m. Instead of going directly to the sales manager, Quo’s Sona or your receptionist answers first.
Caller identification and initial assessment	Manually or automatically asking the caller what they need.	The receptionist would say, “Good afternoon, this is Sarah at ABC Company.
Call evaluation and decision-making	Determining the priority level for your call.	The caller wants a quote, so they need to talk to the sales team.
Call routing or response	Sending the caller to the appropriate destination based on what they need.	Your receptionist or system connects the caller to the sales department.
Documentation and after-call work	Completing after-call work to create a log for future reference.	The call gets logged in your CRM. You can then assign follow-ups if needed.

💡Related: Voicemail vs answering service

How to screen calls like a pro: 4 Best practices 

Here are four best practices to help with screening calls for receptionists:

1. Keep notes on frequent callers to recognize them instantly: Whether it’s VIP clients or persistent salespeople, having caller context helps you adjust your approach immediately. Quo lets you add notes like “VIP” or “sales rep” to contacts to give you more context and bring you up to speed quickly. 

2. Set up business hours routing: Set up different screening approaches for business hours versus after hours. This way, callers can get help 24/7 without you being glued to the phone. For example, you can forward calls to an AI receptionist after hours so people get answers even when no one on your team is available.
3. Let your phone menu filter calls automatically. This is the first line of defense when sorting legitimate callers from spammers. Since robocalls can’t navigate IVR menus, they won’t get through in the first place.
4. Use your call log to spot patterns. Maybe some callers need more support than others, or maybe certain departments have higher spam rates. Look at your call analytics to uncover these patterns. Then, you can make informed decisions about what’s next. This could mean having more hands on deck during peak hours.

3 Popular call screening service options

You don’t need a call center to screen incoming calls for your business.

Here are three options you can choose from instead:

1. AI receptionist built into virtual phone systems 

Best for: Small, medium, and growing businesses, remote teams, and companies that need 24/7 availability without the cost of round-the-clock staff

Pros

• 24/7 availability
• Consistent quality
• Cost-effective scaling
• Never calls in sick
• Can handle multiple calls simultaneously,
• Integrates with business systems

Cons

• May struggle with complex or unusual requests
• Some callers prefer talking to a human

Some business communication tools come with AI voice agents that automatically screen calls. A good example of this is Sona, a virtual receptionist built right into Quo. Sona can answer calls and ask screening questions. It can also take detailed messages, answer FAQs, and transfer calls. You can fully configure how and where you use Sona in your call flow. 

You can also use Sona to handle overflow calls. Or it can hold the fort when you’re on vacation or out for the day. With Quo’s drag-and-drop call flow builder, you can insert Sona wherever you need it, both during and after hours.

Each Sona conversation comes with a call summary and transcript. This gives you clear oversight on every call. Plus, summaries and transcripts mean better record-keeping for compliance, training, or quality assurance.

Unlike human receptionists, you can train Sona in minutes. Not days or weeks. You improve your first response time and give callers the same positive calling experience — all day, every day.

You can try Sona for free with 10 calls per month on every Quo plan. Then, scale up from there as needed.

💡 Learn more: How much does a virtual receptionist cost?

2. Traditional answering services

Best for: Businesses that want human interaction but can’t invest in-house staff

Pros

• More cost-effective than in-house staff
• Human touch for callers,
• Extended hours coverage compared to in-house receptionist

Cons

• Less company-specific knowledge
• Potential quality inconsistencies between operators
• Less control over interactions
• Large ongoing monthly costs

Traditional answering services are third-party companies that provide human operators to answer calls. They usually read from scripts that have basic info about your business. Then, they can take messages, route calls, and even manage appointments.

Answering services cost more than AI receptionists. But they offer a human touch.

Just keep in mind you’ll have less control over these agents’ interactions with customers. Plus, inconsistent answers could hurt your customer satisfaction rates.

3. In-house receptionist or assistant

Best for: Larger businesses with high call volumes or companies where calls require deep company knowledge or complex decision-making.

Pros

• Deep company knowledge
• Personalized service
• Immediate availability during business hours

Cons

• Highest costs
• Limited to business hours
• Requires backup coverage for sick days/vacation
• A single point of failure

An in-house receptionist is a dedicated staff member or virtual assistant. They answer all incoming calls as part of their primary job responsibilities.

In-house receptionists can help callers with more complex decision-making. That’s because they have more firsthand knowledge of your company.

The tradeoff here is the above-average price tag. If this is a full or part-time employee, the costs can be steep. Salaries can be anywhere from $40,000 to $70,000 per year. Plus, as you can guess, people get sick, take vacations, and go on holidays. So you’ll need to plan for backup coverage.

What to look for in a call screening service

When you look for a solution for screening calls for receptionists, focus on:

• Integration capabilities: Does it work seamlessly with your existing phone system and CRM? Avoid service providers that rely on complicated workarounds or wait for hours to email you a call summary. 
• Customizable screening criteria: Can you set rules for calls, business hours, and priority contacts? Is it easy to adjust them quickly if needed?
• Call routing flexibility: Can the system transfer callers to someone? Or ask for specific information depending on the caller’s inquiry? You’ll want a provider that offers more than just answering or voicemail functionality.
• Transparent pricing: Watch for hidden fees like per-minute charges or setup costs.
• Real-time notifications: Can you get instant alerts for priority calls or missed messages? More importantly, can you get them on your preferred channel — text, email, or in-app?
• Call logging and analytics: Does the solution track call patterns? What about response times and caller info? 
• Scalability without complexity: Will the system grow with your business? Or will you need a complete system overhaul as your business grows?
• Trial period availability: Can you test the platform with your team for free? The best services offer free trials so you can test real calls before you decide.

Sona: The best virtual receptionist for growing businesses

The right screening tools make all the difference in building personal customer relationships at scale. 

With Sona, Quo’s AI-powered virtual receptionist, you get 24/7 coverage that’s professional and reliable. It’s one of the easiest ways to simplify screening calls for receptionists and keep every customer interaction on-brand.

See for yourself how this has helped Julee, plus 90,000+ other customers using Quo:

“With Sona, I never worry about missing a call again. It’s like having a smart, reliable assistant who always picks up. It’s professional, friendly, and on 24/7.” — Julee Fels, Branch Manager at Guaranteed Rate

Sign up for a seven-day free trial with Quo to test Sona. If it’s a fit, you can add Sona to your call flow for free for 10 calls a month, then scale up as you need! 

FAQs